Journals are the problem and the solution
This is one of a bunch of posts on what I'm calling 'w4s' -- using the Web, and principles of the Web, to improve science. The others are:He goes on to throw some well-aimed brickbats at the system of publishing and grant reviewing, and how that plays out for researchers who actually do things other than crank out traditional research papers :
- The awesomeness we're experiencing, which provides some examples of current awesomeness in this area.
- The challenges ahead, which covers some of the reasons why academia isn't moving very fast in this area.
- Strategizing for the future, which talks about technical strategies and approaches for helping change things.
- Tech wanted!, which gives some specific enabling technologies that I think are fairly easy to implement.
As an increasing amount of effort is put towards generating data sets and correlating across data sets, funding agencies are certainly trying to figure out how to reward such effort. The NSF is now explicitly allowing software and databases in the personnel BioSketches, for example, which is a great advance. Surely this is driving change?I propose a simple solution : Start better journals.The obstacle, unfortunately, may be the peer reviewer system. Most grants and papers are peer reviewed, and "peers" in this case include lots of professors that venerate PDFs and two-significant-digit Impact Factors. Moreover, many reviewers value theory over practice -- Fernando Perez has repeatedly ranted to me about his experience on serving on review panels for capacity-building cyberinfrastructure grants where most of the reviewers pay no attention whatsoever to the plans for software or data release, and even poo-poo those that have explicit plans. And if a grant gets trashed by the reviewers, it's very hard for the program manager to override that. The same thing occurs with software, where openness and replicability don't figure into the review much. So there's a big problem in getting grants and papers if you're distracting yourself by trying to be useful in addition to addressing novelty, impact, etc.
The career implications are that if you're stupid enough to make useful software and spend your time releasing useful data rather than writing papers, you can expect to be sidelined academically -- either because you won't get job offers, or because you won't get grants when you do have a job.
The fundamental unit of exchange in the academic reputation economy is the publication. At the moment, it is very hard to publish things that are not "normal" research papers. PLOS ONE has helped by shifting the review criteria towards correctness and leaving judgement of novelty to the community. However, PLOS ONE is still nevertheless an awkward place to publish a piece of software, for example.
Tool builders are expected to produce three publications for every one research result. First they have to design, assemble, test and publish the tool. Then they have to write a paper about the tool. Then they have to document the tool. After that, they are expected to release updates, patches and improvements. The only one of these items that "counts" in the academic sense is the one that generates a DOI number -- the paper. This is usually the least valuable of all the things produced. Honestly, how many of you BLAST users have actually read the BLAST paper?
What is needed are journals that let you publish things that aren't strictly papers. It seems perfectly reasonable that a panel of peers should be able review software on my GitHub account and bestow a DOI number on a tag they feel meets the criteria set by the editorial board that badgered them into participating in the review. It seems perfectly reasonable that when I cut a major update of the software, I might submit it for review. This would be extremely wonderful, as it would lead to reviews and critiques the code itself, which almost never happens when one submits an application note.
The same should apply to tool documentation. Science suffers a great deal because documentation is missing, poor, or out of date. The only way to fix that is to let tool builders have their tool documentation reviewed and published. Perhaps some journals might review code only, others documentation only, and others code and documentation together. The same goes for updates. If you want academics to do something, you have to provide rewards in the currency of academia.
It is also important not to overlook things beyond software. What about people building methods and protocols? There are already journals that publish methods papers, but a lot more could be done to make these publications more useful. JoVE, the Journal of Visualized Experiments, is a pretty interesting step in that direction, but much much more needs to be done. Most scientists have no experience whatsoever in video production, narration, editing, or any of the skills needed to make a really good JoVE publication.
There is also another big gap in instrumentation and hardware. Every really productive laboratory has at least one person who builds things. For example, at the UC Davis Genome Center perhaps a third of all the science we publish involve some gizmo built by our in-house machinist Steve Lucero. Steve is definitely what I would regard as a practicing researcher, and has been (ahem) instrumental in a number of important publications. Nevertheless, he was invited to be an author on his first publication only this year. By a graduate student. I don't think this is particularly malicious on the part of the laboratories that use his creations in their work. The problem is that there isn't really a good venue for publishing things.
Booting up new kinds of journals is a long-term endeavor. PLOS ONE is still struggling for acceptability in many circles. Nevertheless, getting researchers to actually look at each others' code would yield rewards in the short term while we wait for the resulting DOIs to be appreciated by the broader scientific community.
You might post on the style for the blog. You should key in that it's killer. Your blog outcome will enlarge your viewers. race face shorts
I wish to show thanks to you just for bailing me, This is one great result after checking through the net and This blog is the first place that help me find this information. I must say I enjoyed reading it, you happen to be brilliant blogger pearly penile papules removal
He goes on to throw some well-aimed brickbats at the system of publishing and grant reviewing, and how that plays out for researchers who actually do things other than crank out traditional research papers
I utterly attitude and revalue your bushel on each and every target.
auravie
Szerezd meg r4 3ds becsléseket a vállalatoktól. abercrombie Háromféle becslések, amelyek közösek a mozgó iparban.
Dopo aver r4 ridotto le scelte a poche società, abercrombie
conoscere e capire i loro contratti.
energy tariffs "View Business electricity prices online. Find cheapest commercial electricity rates from UK energy suppliers. Cheap renewal tariffs call - 0845 226 0046".
Roller Garage Doors "Professional, Excellent product , workmanship and price. I would not hesitate to recommend this company". "Having the security shutters gives us all peace of mind that our business premises are safe". "The Service was second to none from quotation stage to completion.". "The service we received from start to finish was both efficient and very professional". Complement your Home, with a Stylish, Remote Controlled Roller Garage Door, complete with a minimum 2 Year Guarantee! So please click here this link electric roller garage doors
Pure Love Spells At Pure Love Spells we specialize in Love Spells and only love spells, we do not cast any other kind of magic spell. Our sole focus is on matters of the heart, which is why we achieve success for our clients over and over again. To Discover how we can help you, please click here this link breakup spells
So there's a big problem in getting grants and papers if you're distracting yourself by trying to be useful in addition to addressing novelty, impact, etc.
Bookmark Count
I utterly attitude and revalue your bushel on each and every target.
corals @ keppel bay "An ingenious masterpiece, Corals at Keppel Bay rises like an ascending symphony of chords, with its soaring towers and low-rise villa-styled apartment blocks. The alternating heights and double curvature of the towers create a unique interplay of changing light planes and reflecting angles, presenting a spectacular sight at every turn."
stratum condo "Pasir Ris beach and Pasir Ris Park will cater to activities like horseback riding, fishing, biking and rollerblading to provide a balanced living for every member of a family unit. Complementing the convenient access to sports and recreational facilities that future residents can find in Pasir Ris beach and Pasir Ris Park, Stratum condo offers its residents complete and unique facilities scattered over its well-designed landscape."
Bollywood Movies "Watch Free Live TV, Movies, Music Videos and Bollywood Now. Get over 100 TV channels direct to your computer, tablet or mobile phone – Free live streaming by Yamgo.com/"
Lake District Accommodation "Lake District Accommodation is in abundance in the Cumbria and the Lakes region. As well as the superb accommodation the area is home to mountains, forests, family attractions and, of course, lakes. Choose your Lake District Accommodation below, there is something for the whole family to enjoy".
It reveals how nicely you understand this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for more articles.
online gambling
it's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people. rivalta torinese
The career implications are that if you're stupid enough to make useful software and spend your time releasing useful data rather than writing papers, you can expect to be sidelined academically -
Simply have to confess that your article really have adequate knowledge, Please keep up the gratifying work. Feel really happy, You're very smart writer and look forward for more entertaining times reading here queens-hotel-karlsruhe
Watch Free Live TV, Movies, Music Videos and Bollywood Now. Get over 100 TV channels direct to your computer, tablet or mobile phone – Free live streaming by NATURAL DOG TREATS
Belgravia Villas "Developed by Tong Eng Group with sixty years of experience in its stride, you can be assured that every home in Belgravia Villas is built with utmost care and dedication. With such impeccable standards and attention to detail, these homes are bound to last for generations."
Web Hosting Hub Reviews "Pick the the leading and reliable hosting to build a professional site for your company or personal blog that load fast and guaranteed up-time"
Belgravia Villas "Belgravia Villas in Ang Mo Kio Singapore is a rare investment grade cluster homes project to be launched this year."
text your ex back michael fiore "A RebelMouse site for fans of relationship expert Mike Fiore. On this site, you can read reviews of Michael Fiore texts, products, books, PDF downloads, and new releases."
He goes on to throw some well-aimed brickbats at the system of publishing and grant reviewing, and how that plays out for researchers who actually do things other than crank out traditional research papers :
Thanks a lot for providing individuals with a spectacular possibility, I have to voice my passion for your sharpness in writing and giving acknowledges. The post should have magnificent guidance on this important things claire casey capture his heart
I've just decided to create a blog, which I have been wanting to do for a while. Thanks for this post, it's really useful!
sell business
You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.
blank signs
The internet is bogged down with bogus blogs with no real message but the post was fantastic and well worth the read.Thank you for sharing this with me.
should you comment your code
I agree with your blog and i will be back to check it more in the future so please keep up your work. michael kors outleti love your content & the way that you write.
home page
Nice blog and absolutely outstanding. You can do something much better but i still say this perfect.Keep trying for the best.
clarke quay hotel
This is so beautiful and creative. I just love the colors and whoever gets it in the mail will be smiling.
Maryland Hot Tub Repair
I like your post. It is good to see you verbalize from the heart and clarity on this important subject can be easily observed. hormone replacement
forex scalping
You might comment on the analysis of the blog. You should specify it's dazzling. Your blog summary will enlarge your greenbacks.free web hosting
singapore audit firm "Tan, Chan & Partners is a Singapore-based certified public accounting firm established since 1982. We provide statutory audit, tax compliance, and specialised audit services such as auditing for lucky draw and revenue certification amongst others."
an informational youtube page If you would like to learn more about The Hearing Loss Pill, please visit us at http://www.hearinglosspill.com
This is so beautiful and creative. I just love the colors and whoever gets it in the mail will be smiling.
Very informative post! There is a lot of information here that can help any business get started with a successful social networking campaign!
hotspot
Very informative post! There is a lot of information here that can help any business get started with a successful social networking campaign! bitskin
Indian food delivery Tandoor Curry Club (TCC) brings alive the rustic flavors of the ancient Indian cuisine, traditionally famous for its savory "tandoori" dishes and exotic "curries" with an wide range of drinks collections. The exclusive choices of vegetarian and local dishes compliments our menu thus giving TCC the brand of an authentic Indian and Asian cuisine serving to the local community and corporate clients.
Bachelor Degree Arts & Social Sciences, Full Time, Part Time. Communication. Bachelor of Arts (Communication) Awarded by University at Buffalo, The State University of New ...
Serviced apartments THE FOREST BY WANGZ - A brand new urban oasis for the sophisticated traveller, centrally located in the heart of Singapore. With a design that is inspired by the sculptural forms of the lush tropical rainforest, this boutique serviced apartments is dedicated to anticipatory service that is discreet and comfort that is indulgent. Offering flexible short-term and long-term stays, this is a smart choice for the frequent business travellers and savvy tourists.
I like your post. It is good to see you verbalize from the heart and clarity on this important subject can be easily observed. hormone replacement
E Lites cigarette
Must appreciate the great posts you have written here, I was wondering how you could write down in details. This web page has a wide variety of pieces and written in awesome style of writing isle of man estate agents
I believe there are many more pleasurable opportunities ahead for many peoples that looked at your article. Simply wanted to write down a word in order to say thanks to you for those wonderful tips Los Angeles Bail Bonds
This article is an appealing wealth of informative data that is interesting and well-written. I commend your hard work on this and thank you for this information. You’ve got what it takes to get attention.
Read More about Music For Farms
You're so cool! I do wish there were more people like you around on the interwebs. Not many people are careful with their words, including myself sometimes. I have written things I would love to take back, goo work, keep it up.
Buy youtube views We supply millions of YouTube views every day to buyers around the world. Let us help you with video promotion. We offer the lowest prices on YouTube views from real people. Our packages do not include views from bots.
epoxy flooring Toronto Toronto Polished Concrete primary focus is both industrial and commercial polished concrete and epoxy flooring. We repair and resurface most concrete floors to better then new like condition. We service the greater Toronto, and many parts of southern Ontario, Canada.
Awesome article! I want people to know just how good this information is in your article. It’s interesting, compelling content. Your views are much like my own concerning this subject.
Plumbers Dublin
I would also motivate just about every person to save this web page for any favorite assistance to assist posted the appearance.
network marketing, why people fai?
Really a great addition. I have read this marvelous post. Thanks for sharing information about it. I really like that. Thanks so lot for your convene.
sonic games
Men spent enormous amounts of time seeking for them in public. Current level of thinking would amazes anyone. Professional college essay writing service makes everything on time. Consequently, it is also necessary to give a particular attention to the practical aspects of leadership and motivation that means that it is necessary to analyze some practical examples that could reveal its significance.
The attempt to sow discord between the transfer of taiwan and the country has been followed with interest, in this context, cheap Retro jordans be taken to remedy this situation. The Philippines has requested that the official spokesperson of the shoot receive smile! This approach more indifference lives inside the country and the people of Taiwan increases. Taiwanese officials, mainland China to Taiwan in private and the Philippines, China and Taiwan media arrogance warnings not to interfere in its operations, will help to imperialism. Under the current circumstances, China and the Philippines in the dispute South China Sea, there were too aggravating or mitigating circumstances. Philippines, provocation and arrogance of ignorance of mainland China and Taiwan united front against foreign aggression to confront together. Jordan 12 Retro Online The current developments.
This possibility is rarely! Although Taiwan in the country, the authorities are also subject peoples such expectations, but not the leader of the Taiwan authorities. The Philippines, apparently, two rounds of sanctions, it seems that the government of my ying-jeou. In-depth analysis of his personal opinions of Taiwan, that bloodshed, the South China Sea, operate in a sense is absent. Taiwan under oath and the sovereignty of China. Acts rutal! Philippines buzhitiangaodihou behind the United States, China, testing China's provocation. Real Air Jordan 1 Phat Personal use of home and sow discord between the relations between the two sides, making a profit. Ma Ying-jeou the voice of the people of Taiwan, the public is own official seal,
To take strong measures forced the Philippines. Ma Ying-jeou in the Philippines within 72 hours, and an interpretation of the apology Taiwan extra time in the war. Does my ying-jeou in the Philippines. We see now, my ying-jeou one, which is not only because there was no better choice. Although measures were taken to the South China Sea by all means, strong military maneuvers show my ying-jeou, Taiwan, China and the imperialist United States! The Philippines did not really intend and confrontation. Mainland fishermen in the Philippines after the events, Our Jordans For Sale Now the first phase of protests and house condemnation and protests. mty
Posts
